Pie and Mighty

Tried the bbq pulled beef pie and will be going back for more. So good. Also got the chicken parma pie, sausage roll and coffee. All fresh and really delicious!

Best pies in the entire World! Enough said, just go there and you will not be disappointed I promise. I would normally suggest what to have but there really is no point, just pick anything and you will NOT be disappointed. Butter chicken and Beef Vindaloo are my favourites, and Lamb Rogan Josh when its available is a win too. Just buy anything. Oh oh oh, and take some home with you as they reheat magnificently!

The pies I bought from this bakery the first time were below average. I decided to hold off writing a review until coming back for more (in case this was a once off experience).
Today I returned to try the chunky beef pie, and unfortunately, there was no improvement. The meat tasted like processed corned beef. On each of these occassions, the pies were shared with others and they had the same impression. Having said all of that, the service was great! It's just the pies that are not for me.

Just moved to Pakenham and decided to give this place a try for lunch. So glad I did! The gluten free chunky beef pie is hands down the best pie I’ve ever had! So happy to have this place so close.

By FAR the best pies I have ever had! Every single pie is absolutely delicious and cooked to perfection! Explosions of flavour and nice succulent chunks of meat throughout! Been going here for ages and will continue to go until I get sick of pies.which will never happen. (Highly recommend the butter chicken pie, my favourite!)

Maybe the best pies in greater Melbourne. Sadly no need Kelly style pie (with egg in middle) but I'm hoping they'll make one someday

We drove over an hour to here because of all the great reviews and were not disappointed.
As a pie lover who's tried many of the best bakery's around Melbourne these pies were 10 out of 10.
The chunky steak pies were packed with tender juicy meat and more filling than I've ever had in a pie.
Will be back soon.

I'm doing a vego month and admittedly had pretty low expectations. But my lord, their veggie pies are top shelf. I had the Thai veggie and the pumpkin and sour cream pies. The Thai veggie one is one of the best pies I've had. Definitely coming back to try the rest.

Pie and Mighty definitely makes some great pies. I am not a big pie eater/fan. However, I particularly enjoy the coffee, the iced lemon yoyo and the party pie. The coffee is one of the best I've ever had. I find the party pie by far the very best in the country. The iced lemon yoyo is absolutely delicious. I have really enjoyed those with my coffee especially during lockdowns. Thank you to the amazing team at Pie and Mighty for bringing so many smiles on my face even with a face mask on. Please keep the great work. God bless you.

I’d give 5 stars but my friend Connor came over and made me a 5 star worthy butter chicken pie tonight. Thanks

Best pies EVER, I've never eaten an other pie that comes even close to these. They also have the best vegetarian ones.

Fantastic pies. Great range. Cakes too. Particularly like the cold take home family pies. Great staff too.

Nice pies. Friendly staff.
Be quick, as they can run out of your favourite pie by end of the afternoon!

Simply the best meat pies around. Many flavors.shop earlier in the day for fuller range to avoid disappointment Dessert/fruit pies are good too. Friendly service. Recommended.

Family pies here are to die for. Chicken and white wine or Kiev. Well the individual ones are too notch as well. Get some in ya

Wonderful pies the best, had beef vindaloo just full with beef, just so good. The coffee is so good the staff are very lovely thank you so much.

The staff are always friendly. Had the apricot and apple pie the other day. The pastry is so good! I will have to go back and try their savory pies.

Absolutely love this little pie shop.
The owner and his staff are all super friendly and helpful.
The pies here are so delicious, my favourite is Chicken and White Wine but my entire work place absolutely love their Butter Chicken pie.
We do big orders for work on occasion and it seems to be no problem for this very busy store.
Thanks for everything guys.

These pies are on a different level. Most of the time I have to have a reflux tablet after eating a 4 n 20 but there is no repeating action on these. Australian made an Australian owned.
. In fact I’m going to go there now to get some, have a safe and long weekend everybody.

I Recently had a lunch order from school. I orded their sasuage roll and the incredible pie. I would 100% reccomend. Hands down best pie shop in lakeside!