Pie and Mighty

Good pies, including some interesting vegetarian pies. Some nice deserts also. The store is clean and tidy.

Thank you to Will and the entire team for the amazing experience! The pies are absolutely delicious, and the coffee is just perfect. Above all, the service here is outstanding. Highly recommend to anyone looking for great food and a welcoming atmosphere!

Best pie I’ve had from a bakery in years. Would recommend the butter chicken, cooked perfectly. Will comeback

Best pies in Australia. We drove from QLD for a pie from this shop! Bloody awesome! Thanks

Just found the best pie Ive had in years.work/travel a lot and these beat every other bakery out there.easily.
Take note all other bakeries who pretend their pies are good.get lessons on a real pie from here.
Awesome staff too.
Thank you!

Im addicted. Hickory pulled beef has a sweet flavour. Best chunky pies ive had anywhere. Coming from a truckdriver you know ive tried a lot of bakerys. Staff are pleasant and often have to deal with entitled karens and male karens. Coffee is one of the best also.

Great pies with a lot of varieties.

We tried their chicken kiev, chicken parma & cottage pie. All were excellent - fillings are generous and tasty and the pastries are crispy and flaky.

One of the best pies we've ever had!

I’ve been to this cafe twice now and both times the customer service has been appalling. It literally doesn’t cost anything to be polite and smile.

Holy damn

Wholesome, tasty and incredible meals wrapped in pastry - to become a better meal!

If you are reading reviews on a pie shop, it must be because you are considering if their pies are any good.
Also, special mention to the Neenish tart - so many places do it so bad with a huge amount of overly sweet jam and an icing which borderlines cheap confectionery.but not this.the chocolate icing is a treat itself, smooth and velvety on top of a creamy filling and well balanced tart.
Can always judge a place by how well they do the simple things

Simply put.by reading this message, you are wasting valuable pie eating time

Have tried Chicken Kiev, Chicken Avo & Brie and Pulled Beef

I so wanted to give them 5 stars, but their opening hours let them down. Closed early today with just a sign on the window. Only open to 2: 30 on Saturday. Never open Sunday or public holidays. Can’t be the best pies if you can’t buy them.

Im Truck driver and an absolute pie critic. These are the best pies in Melb. I will not tell you my favorite flavour other than its a chunky one on account that they get sold out before 11: 30. Ive introduced others to pies here and we all go out of our way to time pie n mighty into our schedules. Coffee is great as well as are the owners running it. Not a massive selection of cakes but the pies and pasties make up for it hence why I buy 2 pies and dont need a cake.i dont understand matts review on stating he thought the chunkie tasted like corned beef, we have never encountered that.maybe he is sensitive to salt but salt adds flavour to beef.

We wanted to order party pies for our a kids party and mighty pies were default choice. They made butter chicken pies for us and those were just yumm. Kids and their parents both liked them. Thank you for the pies.

Been going here every week for the past 2 years and it's been the same quality everytime. All I can say is that iv tried a lot of other " award winning " pies but nothing compares to Pie and Mighty. Hands down top pies in Australia!

One of these days I will find something there that isn't great. But has never happened. Spicy Mexican it is for me. I realised I never got a coffee there before. Even that was great, staff always great even when busy.

Went and bought this for lunch for the family.it was definitely worth going out of my way for. Great products and wonderful customer service

The pies are so scrumptious and the milkshakes are full of flavour! Will definitely be back.

Tried Chicken Parma and Butter Chicken Pie. One of the best pie I ever had Must try if you are around! Served fresh and hot. Also, serves drinks and dessert! Outdoor seating available.

PS: The filling is fulfilling

Definitely try this place out! These pies are creative, amazing and very, very tasty! Plus, they are hot and ready to eat with excellent pastry. This has to be a Tradie “smoko” favourite.
Also customer service was excellent, I was happily greeted, served and out within 3 minutes. Excellent Pies, truly well done.
So lets break it down

As it was my first time, it was hard to choose as the range is so large it is almost overwhelming.
So I ordered the Original (traditional) gravy mince beef pie and the chicken parma pie. (Refer to Photos)

Price:
Pies start from $5.50 and go up from there. Very reasonable for the food.

Food:
You have to give credit to amazing well-cooked pastry – sometimes that light crackle of thin flaked pastry really tops off every good pie.
The Original Beef Mince pie:
no more or less the traditional meat pie – the beef and gravy were great as it didn’t taste like they added a lot of salt or sugar to pick up the flavour – it was naturally savoury within it’s own right which was excellent.
The Chicken Parma:
Was blown away! So Good! They don’t skip on ingredients, the chicken pieces alone are worth it! But there is every flavour you would expect from traditional pub parma but in this pie. Highly recommend you take the challenge and tell me I’m wrong.

Range:
There would have to be 30 types, I didn’t really count as I was in and out so quickly!

Customer Service:
Service with a smile is always appreciated, thank you for that!
Apart from the service person having to deal with my gobsmacked shock at the variety I was presented with, they had a secondary board to show you what was available – which was very helpful.
Had my pies and paid within a few minutes. Outstanding.

Would highly recommend this shop to everyone – I will be back – if only to try that beef stroganoff pie, which was sadly unavailable at the time.

Sausage roll containing an undercooked paste. Chicken Kiev pie in no way reminiscent of Chicken Kiev. Diet coke rather than "No sugar". Very disappointing after all the positive anticipation. AVOID.

We stopped in on our way through for take away pies. The lamb and rosemary was really lovely as was the bacon and cheese. Hot, tasty and nice pastry, and price was reasonable too! Would return!