OCEANIABIZ.COM

Island Pies

Address 1 Forrest Ave, Newhaven VIC, Australia
Phone +61 3 5956 6089
Hours 06:00-16:00
Categories Bakery, Cafe, Restaurant
Rating 4.5 53 reviews
Similar companies nearby
Burnt Toast — 10 Vista Pl, Cape Woolamai VIC
Beachside Bakehouse — 129 Marine Parade, San Remo VIC

Island Pies reviews

53
Sort by: date highest rated lowest rated most helpful
Pam
02 June 2022 9:42

OMG PORK AND SCALLOP PIE SO GOOD. SAUSAGE ROLLS VERY TASTY. GREAT ARRAY OF CAKES WHICH I AM KICKING MYSELF FOR NOT BUYING SOME
SERVICE EXCELLENT. I AM IN MELBOURNE SO WISH COULD ORDER AND RECEIVE DELIVERY.

Nathaniel
17 May 2022 23:04

Wow. We tried their scallop pie, sausage roll, Thai curry pie and pasty. Bloody delicious. Great pastry!

David
16 May 2022 7:03

The quality & taste of these Pies were incredible. I'll be coming back soon. The coffee was also of a high standard.

Kevin
13 May 2022 19:11

Pies were very good as was the vanilla slice. Strawberry cheesecake tart not so much. Well worth a drop in for the scallop pie.

Christine
08 May 2022 13:54

Great place, lovely pies and cakes.
The only negative that spoils the whe experience is at 2.15pm all the chairs are on the tables inside and outside they are removed. This makes you feel.unwelcome. They are open until 4pm so at 2.15 the staff shouldn't be putting chairs and tables away.

funny
14 April 2022 17:26

The scallop pie was very tasty and unique. Even when the price for it was relatively expensive to your regular pies, it was totally worth it!

Shane
09 January 2022 14:08

Sausage rolls and banana cake we're so tasty, best sausage roll I've had for some time in fact

The milkshakes were great did all in all a terrific experience

Matthew
26 November 2021 18:35

A fantastic array of quality pies and bakery treats well worth the visit sooo yummy. Michelle's service was wonderful too.

Jeff
02 November 2021 6:27

Best pies and pastries on Bass Coast.
Friendly staff and great service.
Definitely worth the stop after you’ve crossed the bridge.

Patricia
16 October 2021 2:41

Best pies, beautiful pastry and tasty fillings. Lots of delicious fresh made rolls and yummy slices, tarts and cake? ? ? Will go back, oh and good coffee

Adrian
15 September 2021 18:16

Was looking forward to the scallop pie all week and 2 seconds after I buy the pie and try to start eating it, the bottom of the pie falls apart and it completely disintegrates. Not happy Jan.

Merryl
02 September 2021 2:46

New was was rather boring inside and brought a steak bacon and cheese pie only to burn my mouth on as I took a bite and fell apart as well. Not a lot of flavor because had a lot of mince meat in it.
NO STAFFasked if I had coded in to the shop and NO staff had masks on so very sus on cleanliness or sanatising around the area etc.
Will find another bakery and have heard Beachside Bakehouse have really good food there.

Heymann
10 August 2021 9:33

An excellent bakery for great pies. The steak and mushroom pies were so delicious and the coffees fantastic. Really was thrilled by how great it all was, had to get a vanilla slice to round it out. That was perfect as well, the go to place!

Erin
10 August 2021 7:15

Best Pies and Coffee going around. The staff are so friendly and accommodating for all requests. The new Shop is lovely and fresh. I would give them 10 stars if I could!

Dale
01 August 2021 22:07

Best bakery ever! Out of all my favourite bakery’s over the years, if you took every one. And put all their best quality’s into one. GreT food, allways welcomed, great friendly service

flicks
24 July 2021 16:15

Without a doubt the best bakery around. Emma and her staff are so nice to their customers. They have the best pastry around

Mary
06 July 2021 8:29

Great selection of pies, know for their scallop pies. Pasties, sausage rolls, lovely selection of sandwiches, cakes etc.
Lovely HOT coffee, (as we all know some bakeries don't make coffee hot just warm). Staff lovely, seating in and outside available and carparking available.

Eng
12 May 2021 10:13

One of the oft-mentioned bakery/cafe on Phillip Island by friends who had been there. Decided to have a pit-stop for pies and coffees. Famous as the home of scallop pies! Good Amati brewed coffee. Tasty pies. Friendly staff.

Niki
02 May 2021 23:50

Quick stop off on our way home. Great coffee and hot chocolate. Sausage rolls, pies and pasties were delicious. Staff friendly. Shop could do with a bit of a clean and freshen up. Would buy from here again and recommend.

Marisa
07 March 2021 10:56

Old school, but fresh and delicious. Pies have a good mix and variety and strudel and custard tarts were super fresh. Worth a visit.

Add review