OCEANIABIZ.COM

Gemma Simply Italian

Address 183 Elgin St, Carlton VIC, Australia
Phone +61 3 9349 2835
Hours
Wednesday17:00-22:00
Thursday17:00-22:00
Friday17:00-22:00
Saturday17:00-22:00
Sunday17:00-22:00
Website www.gemmasimplyitalian.com.au
Categories Pizza Restaurant, Gluten-Free Restaurant, Italian Restaurant, Pasta Shop, Restaurant
Rating 4.4 71 review
Similar companies nearby
Carlton Pizzeria — 160 Rathdowne St, Carlton VIC
+39 Pizzeria — 362 Little Bourke St, Melbourne VIC
Silvio's Pizza House — 320 Bridge Rd, Richmond VIC
Gradi at Crown — 8 Whiteman St, Southbank VIC

Gemma Simply Italian reviews

71
Sort by: date highest rated lowest rated most helpful
Nadira
26 January 2022 9:08

Lovely place! It has such a nice cosy atmosphere. The food was super fresh and delicious, and they went above and beyond to put extra ingredients as their own offer.

Run by a wonderful waiting team, I appreciate their patience and service so much, I can't put it into words. Definitely reccomend!

Jon
23 January 2022 15:09

Although they were busy and had less staff. We received our food within 15-20mins of ordering. Both wait staff were lovely and attentive. Portions could have been a little bigger but the food was delicious!

Chanel
21 January 2022 23:55

Delicious, authentic Italian. Great value for money. Really good customer service. Would highly recommend.

Fernando
24 November 2021 16:24

The pizza was delicious!
The customer service was even better! They gave us tiramisu on the house!

Sean
16 November 2021 0:41

My go-to place for an authentic Italian cuisine experience. Even during lockdown, they are still serving incredibly tasty food with passion and friendliness. Forza Napoli!

Josephine
12 November 2021 13:33

Very delicious food, super friendly staff and great service! Highly recommend, will definitely be back. Grazie mille!

Tabitha
16 September 2021 11:13

You know it's good food when you crave it the next day and then book to go back the week after! Love your work Gemma

Chung-Huey
13 September 2021 0:51

Enjoyed the delicious seafood spaghetti, capricciosa, and tiramisu (as a surprise gift!) Staff are friendly and responsible. Highly recommended

Maricris
05 September 2021 2:48

Pizza and carbonara was good, but would suggest for the carbonara to have been creamier and have more guanciale please

Tom
01 September 2021 15:53

I had a great meal here with a bunch of friends. Quite often vegetarian options at Italian restaurants just aren't up to standard but the food at Gemma was fantastic. I will certainly be back!

Katerina
25 August 2021 1:33

The gnocchi dish I got was disappointing! Bland and not much flavour, supposed to have basil but came with one basil leaf! Had weird clumpy cheese on top that didn't go with the dish and the meal was cold. The waiter was not friendly and took forever to take our order, it literally took an hour to get our food! Not cool considering we needed to go to a movie after and were not expecting such slow service.

Daniela
14 August 2021 12:27

A wonderful dining experience. Visited with my partner and family. We had delicious pizzas, with bases that reminded me of my trip to Italy. Definitely recommend for dinner and dessert - the nutella calzone was delicious. Staff are very kind and welcoming. 5/5

Steven
09 August 2021 17:00

Gemma Simply Italian is amazing. Food. Ambience. Staff. All 5 stars. The minute you walk in you get this warm rush of air and the vibe is amazing. Definitely a must go, we had the gnocchi and two pizzas and everything was perfect, we then finished with a hot chocolate, Nutella calzone and tiramisu which was divine!

Derwin
05 August 2021 22:23

You will GNOCCHI be disappointed!
Here on a Wednesday for $15 woodfired pizza! Regina Bianca my absolute favourite, pears on a pizza just works when it's made by these guys.
Gnocchi were small servings, but absolutely delicious.
Chilli oil and extra cheese also brought in without asking.
Service was friendly and attentive, kudos to the chef who let me place one last order to go!

Bianca
04 August 2021 5:25

Amazing. Absolutely amazing. Cannot fault, food is incredible and the service is impeccable. Highly recommend!

susie
23 July 2021 4:09

Gemma Simply Italian is hard to beat - a delightful, cosy, family run restaurant with an authentic Italian atmosphere. The pasta and pizza dishes are always fresh, delicious and beautifully presented, while the friendly staff go out of their way to make customers feel welcome. A perfect place to dine casually or to celebrate with friends. No wonder it's popular - make sure to book at week-ends!

D
16 July 2021 21:19

Loved this place for a casual dinner with friends.

The staff were friendly and attentive, great drink options, and food was nice.

The only negative was the rice dish that was served in a fry pan. It tasted okay but it was odd eating out of a kitchen grade non-stick frypan and would have preferred a normal plate.

Farah
20 June 2021 9:38

One of the best experiences I have had at an Italian Restaurant. The pizza and the pasta we ordered were delicious! And probably some of the freshest and flavourful pasta I have had. I usually find cheese gnocchi quite sickening, but this gnocchi was very well balanced.

Just from looking around, you can definitely tell that this family owned business puts in a lot of work to make sure every person is well catered to.

The staff were also so friendly and accommodating and the overall ambiance is unmatched. I have never been to a restaurant, and felt so cozy and 'at home' while enjoying my meal.

Do yourself a favour, and try this place! You won't be disappointed!

Bilal
05 April 2020 6:55

Best pizza and pasta ever! Among all other italians restaurants, it is the best in the area, pizza reminded me of my trip to italy, so authentic

Maria
20 February 2020 19:44

Fast service tasty food. I had to make changes due to being pregnant the staff were very accommodating and even open the door when the restaurant got too hot

Add review