OCEANIABIZ.COM

Gemma Simply Italian

Address 183 Elgin St, Carlton VIC, Australia
Phone +61 3 9349 2835
Hours
Wednesday17:00-22:00
Thursday17:00-22:00
Friday17:00-22:00
Saturday17:00-22:00
Sunday17:00-22:00
Website www.gemmasimplyitalian.com.au
Categories Pizza Restaurant, Gluten-Free Restaurant, Italian Restaurant, Pasta Shop, Restaurant
Rating 4.4 71 review
Similar companies nearby
Carlton Pizzeria — 160 Rathdowne St, Carlton VIC
+39 Pizzeria — 362 Little Bourke St, Melbourne VIC
Silvio's Pizza House — 320 Bridge Rd, Richmond VIC
Gradi at Crown — 8 Whiteman St, Southbank VIC

Gemma Simply Italian reviews

71
Sort by: date highest rated lowest rated most helpful
Erica
26 December 2023 8:14

Truly authentic Italian from the decor to the food. Happy to have found this hidden gem, it will be a regular on our list.

Pizza, pasta and dessert couldn’t be more perfect! The staff were all so friendly and service was quick and generous. Our one year old was given garlic bread which was such a generous and kind gesture.

Highly recommend this place, you won’t leave hungry or disappointed that’s for sure! Can’t wait to return

TBA
06 December 2023 19:02

Good enough. Nice mushroom pizza, and at a bargain price on a Wednesday. Gnocchi themselves good but can't recommend the ragu option. For a start, it's not a ragu! And taste was sub par. But other pasta dishes we saw going past all looked good, so we'll be back. Delicious salad and good portion size. Great service. For a pizza/pasta place, a stubby of Moretti at $10.90 is stretching the friendship a little, but wine and cocktail prices are reasonable so it all works out. Gemma is definitely worth you trying.

Mauro
10 September 2023 11:04

This was real. Probably not 100% as in the motherland (I am Italian, 100%. I grew up overseas and just came back from the usual yearly meet up with the family in Italy), but close, very close. Not everyone makes Carbonara with the Guanciale, egg and cracked pepper.and the menu clearly says "Spaghetti Carbonara" Not penne, or ravioli, or farfalle or whatever. Compliments. Will definitely be back!

Shivam
08 September 2023 20:31

A true Italian restaurant that deserves 5 stars for its hospitality, food and quality.
While on holiday in Australia we found this restaurant to be fantastic with exceptional product quality.
From the appetizer, first pizza and dessert, everything is like being in Italy
Well done
I would go back there again

Barbara
03 September 2023 10:04

I never go to Italian restaurants because for me nothing is ever as good as Nonnas Gnocchi…. The food was amazing and of quality… Will go again A+

Stephen
19 August 2023 15:48

My dad and I come here all the time. Great for vegans and everyone else. Excellent service and food!

Jackie
21 July 2023 7:42

Gemma Simply Italian was the perfect choice for our family celebration. Incredible food, and the service and staff were amazing. Nothing was too much trouble. Thank you so much for a wonderful night. We will be back!

Julie
13 July 2023 17:55

Delicious pizza. A cosy little restaurant with authentic Italian dishes. I will be back to try the gnocchi and tiramisu next time.

jocelyn
10 July 2023 20:14

We didn't have a booking but the staff were so kind and accomodating.we ordered the garlic foccacia, margherita, peppino, beef ragu gnocchi and seafood spaghetti.all were to die for and so so good this place is such a gem.the tiramisu is great as well!

J
07 July 2023 2:11

Amazing food but it is the staff that makes me love this place, gorgeous service that filled me with cheer as much as the pizza

Melissa
19 February 2023 8:58

Gnocchi melts in your mouth and is gluten free!
Woodfield pizza is cooked well, all the right qualities of soft dough that is chewy and crispy and good flavours.
Good value and atmosphere.

Lotte
17 February 2023 11:31

Lovely little authentic italian restaurant. Very kind people who go above and beyond to make sure you have the best experience which cannot go wrong with the delicous food they offer.

user
14 February 2023 10:33

The food was amazing and the staff were so lovely! Would absolutely recommend this awesome cozy place!

Amiel
27 January 2023 2:26

I’ve been here many times before and I couldn’t be happier with the service I’ve received. I’ve always had the pizza and gnocchi but today I also tried the dessert. The Panna Cotta is to die for!

jase
20 January 2023 21:55

Really good pasta options! So yum.although did have to get my own cutlery.staff all friendly and chatty thank you

Giuseppe
19 January 2023 5:13

Food was great
The pizza and pasta all great but the fettuccine with read meat sauce i really liked

Rohan
17 January 2023 8:27

This restaurant has a fantastic vibe to it and an even friendlier owner. Today we only had desert, my favourite being the tiramussu. We will 100% be back and cannot wait to try their famous pizzas.

Steven
16 January 2023 10:11

Great food! Very friendly and welcoming staff! Strongly would reccomend! Even better on a Wednesday for $15 pizza!

user
11 January 2023 16:44

We had the pear and Gorgonzola gnocchi and the Raghu it was some of the best pasta we’ve ever had! It was very busy and they managed to fit us as a table of 6!

Joey
30 December 2022 10:59

Mamma mia! Our little piece of Italy here. Woodfired pizza cooked to perfection. So as the home-made gnocchi al forno e ravioli. Simply Buonissimo! Viva Italia!

We will come back for more. 100%

Add review