The Bay Pizzaria

Really really nice pizza. Pizza base and ingredients all outstanding. Friendly staff and beautiful dine in area. Must try when you visit the area.

Our whole meal was great, definitely coming back for more soon. Thanks for a great meal and service

Had the crayfish today with my son, best pizza I've had in many years, delicious. Thank you guys

Wow, saw the reviews here so decided to try. Big statement but the best pizza we have ever had! We had the veggie and vegan veggie pizzas. If you are nearby or at Mount Gambier definitely worth the visit for pizza by the water ️

Stayed in Port Macdonnell for the weekend - attended the Generations in Jazz 2023 festival - and needed a quick bite to eat. The pizza's were fantastic, hard to separate between the crayfish and meet the meats pizza. Crayfish pizza won narrowly. Service was excellent too.

Had a great time the pizza was great and the staff was better I did however miss my chance to suggest cheesy stuffed crust but that’s ok it on here so that’s good damn cheap price for pizza essentially the seafood pizza with how expensive that is so I tip my hat to u on the fair and honest pricing for my first visit here I’m definitely coming back and and the fact it was a great lunch there made my 30th birthday great so with this review being 5 stars I’m definitely gonna be going back and if that’s a success like I know it will be I hope to give you another 5 star review

Visited The Bay Pizzaria as it was recommended by someone in Mount Gambier. It did not disappoint and I highly rate their pumpkin pizza.

Pizza I'd always amazing here love the coyness of the old local but the new site is much better suited

Awesome pizza's as always, new shop is very noisy and echoes with everyone talking, will probably get take away from know on

Amazing food, lovely customer service!
The atmosphere was very relaxing and inviting.

New building, same great view, even better pizzas than before- which is a hard goal to beat.

Tasty as! Spicy buffalo chicken is our fave, but you really can’t go wrong with any of the pizzas. The ingredients are gourmet and the base is everything you want in a pizza crust. We always recommend this place to visitors and it never disappoints!

Ordered a "BBQ chook" pizza. We had to get takeaway as there were no tables available. Drove to our destination to dig in to find they had drizzled the pizza with tomato sauce not BBQ.ruined the whole thing. For $23 really didn't enjoy.

Couldn’t resist a crayfish pizza from Australia’s southern cray capital. Surprisingly good pizza from a little beachside town. Highly recommend grabbing the cray cray, adding some chilli and maybe even asking for a second lemon wedge. Delicious guys, keep up the great work!

OMG! The crayfish pizza is delish! The first ever tried and definitely a flavour bomb! We also had the Prawn Star pizza and was great too! Love the pizza dough. Not dry and cooked perfectly. Also had the finger licking good wings - both in House BBQ and Honey Soy seasoning. Definitely worth a place to visit!

Absolutely great place. Staying just south of Mount Gambier, so this is only 20mins drive. Pizzas were delicious - I had the cray cray special - lovely and fresh and so tasty. Mine disappeared down my stomach too fast for me to stop for photos. Also really nice cocktails. For the indecisive they also do half and half pizzas. Definitely recommend.

Saturday night. Girl at counter not very friendly. Needs more training greeting and talking to people.

Wow what an amazing meal!
The dijon mustard pizza and butter chicken calzone where fantastic, lightening quick friendly service, cannot wait to go back.

This is one of the most wonderful places to eat. GF options Vegan options. But overall wonderful food and drink. We come to the south east just to come here

Well the girl I'm seeing must have enjoyed it because she asked me to go official after eating here. Must have been the pizza.
Vegan options are good. Pizza is delicious. Good range of drinks. If it wasn't nighttime, the view of the beach would have been even better. The staff were friendly. Would 10/10 add them to FB. Footy was on- big plus.