The Sherlock Holmes

Food was good but service could definitely improve. When I made a booking the woman who answered the phone actually sighed. Took ages for us to get a menu after we were seated, waitress took away our glasses before our drinks were finished. Overall a disappointing experience.

Pub grub, food is a expected, doesn't pretend it's something it's not. On a negative, this is an English/Irish style pub. It's beer range is uninspiring, especially when both its dark tap beers are "not available" and the darkest beer it offers is a Red Ale.

We tried to have lunch here, we checked in and were seated by the staff only for the manager to rudely kick us out because of a future booking. I understand if a restaurant is booked out my problem is with the way it was handled, the manager was quite rude and made out like we just plonked ourselves into a table without asking.

The food was awesome. Steak cooked to perfection. Chips super crunchy, sticky date pudding with iceceam very good. Plus cider on tap irresistible.

The meals were overcooked, they sat on the hatch waiting for staff to collect for ages.our reserved table was occupied and we were just given someone else's.

First time at the Sherlock Holmes.really enjoyed our meal. We had the Beef and Guineas pie with fries and gravy. Wish it came with veg like carrots and peas.
But the pie was delicious. Hubby had the Aussie Schnitzel.with fries and salad.could not fault it.
We will be sure to go back and try the another meal from the lovely choice of British food
Hope they have Hot chocolate also next time.

The food was great.especially as it was a cold day appreciated the pub type meal I had. Atmosphere is great.

We came here for a quick drink, and just loved how it's tucked away in the basement of Collins Street. They have great selection of tap beer.

Definitely coming back to try their food. We were informed that we need to book in advance, as it gets very packed on the weekends.

Stopped in for lunch and had the mushroom risotto. Very nice. They have a few vegetarian options. But even the bangers and mash that went past looked pretty damn good.

Nice english pub, very good looking place. The food is great, except when it’s busy. You can notice that the chef is rushing and putting zero effort on the meals (ej. No dressing on the salad).
The staff seem not caring at all about the customers. The blond waitress today threw our cutlery very rudely onto the table rather than placing it down and make us feel comfortable.
They need to make some changes.

Great name, excellent English pub vibes, nice beer. My food was quite tasteless and hard to eat so loses points for that.

Lovely venue, fabulous hosts very friendly. Meals were larger than it looked and the beef roast just melted on your mouth. Absolutely delicious. Would definitely recommend.

Very friendly staff, but clientele were messy: smoking in the doorway because of the rain, blocking access to toilets in groups due to lack of free tables and literally collapsing from chairs in a heap from the table next to us. We didn't order meals, but the presentation of dishes going to other tables looked excellent and worth a return trip. This may also be the closest trivia venue to the office, so I'm keen to try again.

Great pub. Exceptional food. Good wine list. Lots of beers and friendly staff. A must to visit when in Melbourne CBD. Still my favourite pub in 2021. Melbourne cbd for great wine, beer choices and really good food.top value and still friendly service.

Awesome English Pub, really felt like I was in the U. K again. I had veal schnitzel with chips & coleslaw which was really scrumptious. Good selection of beers too. Cheers Lads!

First time here and the staff are great and welcoming, and the food is just amazing I had a good feed. And I'll coming back again

A warm, inviting space with lots of thoughtful decor and comfortable seats. Great beer, good food. Can get a bit crowded, but most patrons are considerate and help you shuffle to fit!

Staff we so helpful and friendly, the food was amazing definitely got my moneys worth. The whole vibe of the place is so different to other places but so good. Highly recommend!

Quirky beer names (Brexit ale) and great tucker add up to an easily cozy choice for pub grub. Slightly pricey food with the portions nearly compensating the premium - we had the bangers and mash and the fish and chips. Well cooked Cumberland sausages on a bed of good mash with flavoursome gravy ticked all the right boxes on a cold night. Fish and chips hit the mark per my partner and the cheery service always helps. We indulged in the apple pie and were pleasantly surprised with the crisp crust and the spicy and not too sweet filling.

Great food in a charming atmosphere, but do yourself a favour and don't order a hot chocolate or coffee! The hot chocolate was just cooking cocoa powder in milk - clumped and super bitter. Disgusting.