Miss Pickle 1971 Casey Central

Absolutely bummed! Paid extra for $2 to replace chicken to lamb as my daughter doesn’t eat chicken, got home and turns out to be chicken! Fries are stale. The pita was ok.
Waited 30 min for the food to be ready. $12 went to waste, what a shame! Absolutely disappointed! As I told the lady that took my order so many times, LAMB and even paid extra for it!

Our first time visiting for a meal and the food was excellent. Lots of flavour and good size servings. We shared our meals. Service was great and we will be back.

I have absolutely no faults whatsoever! I had an open souvlaki as one of my first meals after coming home from hospital following major surgery last year and it did not disappoint! I come back regularly now and everything I tried on the menu so far has been amazing! The staff have been incredible and they treat everyone like they are a member of their family. I came in one evening and the staff were very busy due to high demand, but they all did such an amazing job to ensure that everyone customer was happy. Miss Pickle Casey has become my favorite spot and I would highly recommend it to anyone.

Miss Pickle is my favourite go to place for a good feed. Every time I go, I’m greeted with a smile, particularly by Maria. She is an excellent brand ambassador and a credit to your team!

Worst service ever. Walked in for lunch today and after 30 minutes of placing the order a staff member came and asked again what was the order. After another 15 minutes of waiting again we were approached and said our order was still not placed. We had to walk off so irritated and starving there for no reason. Better get their act straight. Will surely not recommend this place to anyone.

Do yourself a favour and try the new management at miss pickle casey central. Our experience both times we went was amazing. My mother in law had a fantastic birthday dinner thanks to the wonderful staff. The food was delicious and very generous sizes. The cocktails were on point. Don't let the past experiences with the old owners deter you from trying it again, highly recommend!

Pictured is the feed me platter for 2!

Good customer service, food on the other hand, not so good. The meats from the grill/spit all had the same incredibly sweet fake tasting marinade which was very overpowering.
For $55 per person, I would have expected better quality, I also assume they ran out of pita bread as our platter was filled with store brought pita.not good enough really!

The worst Greek place ever. Ordered mixed gyros. The server couldn't even confirm what meat was in it but made sure no lamb. Of course it came out with lamb so got changed to chicken gyros but still got charged extra because the price on the menu was apparently wrong and their system says so. (Please go read Price displays on ACCC and Consumer affairs!)

Ordered a drink they mentioned was part of happy hour menu but still get charged the full price. (How would I even know about it, which was not even on the menu.)

The worst part was the most soggy baklava I've ever had in my life. Had so many baklavas but never had this bad but apparently this is their "Fresh" one and its normally this soggy. Also blamed that it could be because of being on the ice cream.no you can see the pastry is not even properly baked. You can also see from other reviews that this is not even how it's served.clearly couldnt crush them considering how soggy it was.

Please go drive 20-30 mins more to Oakleigh to have a decent Greek food.

We had two waitresses Maya and another girl Maya served us and she was amazing me had a mixed mezze plater and two open souvlaki’s one with loukaniko and one with pork skewers which she recommended us she was kind and very helpful would definitely recommend this place and come back and visit service was lovely ️

Very disappointed in their food and portions service is good staff lovely. They were good when opened now gone down hill nothing like their Knox store where the food and portions are great. Casey give up on the potatoes and bring back the chips. I had and open mixed plate hardly no meat but it had about 1/4 plate if not more full of oily potatoes they did say there is a potatoes shortage that’s why there are no chips but there are plenty of potatoes to make their oily potatoes portions go figure that one out

Excellent service and delicious food. Staff are very friendly and servings are great for price. Usually visit restaurants/takeaways shops once and like to try other shops but this one I will definitely return.

Great food, great ambience and the staff are very friendly and helpful. Special shout out to Maria, who has been amazing all three times that I’ve been there. She was super helpful and ensured that we picked the best food and drinks from the menu. Thanks Maria

Probably the best customer service we've ever had! Genuine & kind attention to detail. Lovely food too and so good to arrive during happy hour! Thank you

Been here a few times with the girls for happy hour, the cocktails are amazing and during happy hour only $10 with a good variety to pick from! Not only do they have cocktails but they also have food options under the happy hour promo as well as basic house spirits, beer and wine. The food served looked amazing, the serving staff are lovely, very friendly and well mannered. Did i mention happy hour is every day between 3pm -6pm! How good is that? !? ! So 100% head down to Miss Pickles 1972 Casey with a few friends for a nice little happy hour catch up!

First time trying it, I’m little disappointed that the lamb tasted bland dry no flavour I suspect it was cooked and heated up.and carelessly prepared. Barely had chips
Prices? To be fair Bit expensive for sure. I hope to try again soon.

Had a really nice experience at Miss Pickle Casey Central.food was very nice, drinks were unique and desserts (especially the gelato) were delicious.highly recommend

Expected a bit more for what i paid, chicken gyros was dry and lacked flavour, calamari was rubbery, portions were not on par with price. The chips and the pita were about the only good things, friendly staff too but id advise spending your money elsewhere

This place was amazing! Thank you for the lovely experience! The staff helped a lot with our menu choices and the food was tasty!
They are very friendly and talkative to socialise with!
Definitely try this place out!

We've eaten at the Glen Waverley restaurant before which we enjoyed so we're excited to find this one closer to home. Unfortunately the food and cocktails both were not great and went home a little disappointed after spending $120 on dinner. The staff tried hard but it was the food that let them down.

Been going since they opened and we have never had a bad experience or meal. Awesome service always and we prefer to dine in to get the food fresher then delivery!
Keep it up legends