Miss Penny Cakes

Tried numerous times to order a birthday cake. No response from owner. Went into store and was directed to her website. Emailed her 3 times, no response. I even called the shop and she didn’t get on the phone. I could hear her telling the lady who answered to email her and she’ll reply by the end of the day. That didn’t happen.
Worst communication in a business I’ve ever experienced

We LOVED our wedding cake. It fit the boho theme well and was the most delicious cake I have ever eaten. I highly recommend Miss Penny Cakes! Great customer service too

Our cupcakes order was Amazing! It looked even better than the picture I had sent with my request and the taste, oh my goodness, so delicious! Thanks Penny, I only wish I could bake like this.

Miss Penny Cakes-Thank you so much for the awesome Sonic cake you created for my son's 8th Birthday! He absolutely loved it and the fact that he could keep the 3 Sonic toys was a bonus. I'm so glad I found you and you will now be my 'go to' Miss Penny Cakes. A +

I just had my 30th Birthday cake made by Penny. She absolutely smashed it out of the park! It looked and tasted amazing. I am still receiving compliments on my cake. Penny is great with her communication and was great in working with me to make sure I got what I wanted. I could not recommend her more! Would definitely order a cake again and also go to her Cafe for some delicious cakes!

The cake Penny made was an incredible hit at my husband's surprise 50th birthday party. So many guests came up to me and told me how good it was. I had a dozen of her gluten free cup cakes as well and the guests who were gluten intolerant raced about those as well. Even my husband, who really could take or leave desserts made a point of telling me how amazing the flavour was. So thank you so much. It looked incredible and we all loved it. I'll definitely be recommending you to friends in the future.
Emma

WOW! I had Penny do my sons first birthday cake, cookies and cupcakes and they were incredible. It was safari themed and she absolutely nailed it. She was also a delight to deal with throughout the process and I truly felt like everything was made with love. Thankyou Penny!

Great environment with delicious bakery options and coffee. Can't think of a better bakery in Melbourne!

We had a cake made for my husband's 50th birthday and it looked incredible and well beyond my expectations! The taste was to die for, and we struggled to share it! It was so moist and full of flavour! Highly recommend! He might get another for his 51st now!

Amazing home-made pastries and sweets, literally all of them are super tasty every time! Try the spanakopita or any of the custard deserts. I love the iced mochas too. My fave Saturday treat:)

Not nice at all. Ordered galaktaboreko. It was an old refridgerated piece for $7.50. You could feel it in the texture and the custard felt like glue. Very disappointing.

Wonderful array of sweets and savoury treats to choose from! Had a vegan pie, quiche, Mediterranean toasty, carrot cake and they were all yummy

Ordered a birthday cake for my daughter this past weekend. It was everything I expected plus more. The cake, icing, and decor was divine! Well worth the price I paid. Thank you Penny!

Thank you so much Penny for creating the most beautiful mermaid cake for my daughter she couldn’t have been anymore excited. You brought her dream cake to life it was beyond anything we could have imagined.
And the added bonus of was it tasted so delicious, everyone commented how lovely it tasted.

Always a yummy indulgence especially given that the cakes r just so incredibly irresistible not to b missed.
Cute n small it's got a local following & tbh I think & beyond.
A gr8 pick me up spot - u gotta taste each one of those special Greek cakes & then start again just to b sure
UPDATE 24 June 2022
Wonderful sit down with a magik custard pudding on the recommendation of a staff member. She was a 100% on the money too & i washed it down with a slight slant of my ice coffee.
Take home Baclava & Spanakopita - borh sure to please as well.
I luv my visits here

Cannot recommend Miss Penny Cakes enough! I ordered 16 mini vegan cupcakes to be delivered and they were absolutely delicious. So grateful to Penny who made the booking and payment process so easy. So lucky to have such an amazing cake shop locally and can't wait to order again in the future.

Highly Recomended
Fantastic cakes, bread and pastries.
Good atmosphere
Excellent coffee
Don’t hesitate to visit.

I can't speak highly enough of Miss Penny Cakes. I contacted them 2 days before a hastily reorganised post-lockdown birthday party for my son and they prepared this masterpiece.and the cake was delicious too. Thank you, Miss Penny!

They sometimes put a little tiny bit of cake on top of my coffee cup and that just makes my day. I mean I don't wanna sentence them to a lifetime of giving away free cake, I'm just saying they sometimes do. Don't be hassling them for free cake OK, that's not on. The coffee is great.

Best egg and bacon rolls and coffee! An amazing range of yummy treats and phenomenal customer service!