Coffin Sally

Staff were saying rude words to the street. This is not acceptable anymore. Which makes this embarrassing for the community of portfairy.

Cosy and laid back dining area.
Good pizza. Great margs. Good vibes.
Kid friendly. What more could you want.
Thanks guys

Pro tip: ask for the secret menu item

We ate here at the end of our Great Ocean Road drive—great atmosphere, nice people, good food, good beer, good prices.

Getting a bit average guys.
Pizza base is average no great flavour 25 buks for a 10 dollar Pizza

Lift ya game.maybe try some salt and pepper even.i guess because we get so much tourists you aren't to worried about return customers?

Or have you become money grubs.spends less make more

Pizza was really good 4/5, however, I found the pizza dough itself could’ve been cooked just a little more to make it the bit nicer. Nevertheless, great pizza. The team was really nice and all there produce is fresh and tasty! Oh and it isn’t really dine in just few tables outside - small shop (this didn’t affect the mark).

Absolutely great service, straight to seeing us, amazing flavour (tried the buffalo sally, spinner and the prawn), and very relaxed friendly area to sit down.

Absolutely one of my favourite places to eat.

Delicious pizza - we opted for the Napoletana and the mushroom (white), and the mushroom was a definite fave! Crispy pancetta and well seasoned mushrooms (only wish they were a bit more chopped as some were quite chunky still for pizza topping), really yummy and well cooked base! For those that need them the gluten free options were accessible and readily available too.

The workers are careless they have put fish instead of prawns for the third time when we specifically told them not to. I hope they improve

A great range of pizzas
Not just the ordinary lame pizza menu thankfully.
If you want a new favourite pizza cooked well go to Coffin Sally

Great, interesting pizza. Thin base and a variety of flavours. One favourite, blue cheese and pear.

There are so many great things to say about this place. The vibe is extremely unique, such a cool Voodoo-esque interior. The cocktails are absolutely brilliant. The pizza, incredible, a really well thought out and varied menu, everything was well seasoned, just super tasty. It's just so so dope. Me and my partner had an awesome time. Thanks!

There are so many great things to say about this place. The vibe is extremely unique, such a cool Voodoo-esque interior. The cocktails are absolutely brilliant. The pizza, incredible, a really well thought out and varied menu, everything was well seasoned, just super tasty. It's just so so dope. Me and my partner had an awesome time. Thanks!

What a great pizza. Not only were the staff friendly and able to handle special requests, but more importantly the pizzas were fabulous and were a cut above your ordinary pizzas.
Would thoroughly recommend this pizzeria to anyone travelling through Port Fairy.

We stop in Port Fairy every year just to eat this pizza. It’s worth it every time. Also great selection of drinks of the grapes and grains varieties you want while munching on a good piece of wood fired dough.

Pizza dough, not sure about, taste more like a flat bread, can’t put my finger on it, sauce, toppings not bad! But pizza is all about the dough, this is not quite right!

Grabbed two pizza's the pig one and the potato one. Very tasty, not skimpy on topping but not overdone either. Very thin but delightful base. Shopfront service. Really great experience and would recommend anyone who enjoys pizza to try Coffin Sally. I'll be back again for sure.

Great pizza, really enjoyed the mushroom and the mexicana and would’ve loved to come back and try the rest. Drink selection was great, and the wood fire inside the bar was a great vibe

Booked out, but the guy on the phone suggested we do a walk up and maybe sit outside, which we did. A bit cold, but the pizza made up for it. Great pizza, wine and staff.

Fantastic experience - the mushroom pizza was delicious and bar by the fire was great on a cold evening.

Amazing pizzas, we considered going back for more after scarfing down two of them. Despite being under the pump as one of the only places open in town due to a COVID staffing crisis, service was friendly and the food ready exactly when we were told it would be. Would love to come back again when its not takeaway only.