458 Pizzeria

Amazing pizza, best I've ever had! Service was outstanding and the owner Alex was extremely hospitable and made me and my wife feel welcome. Highly recommended 5 out of 5. Best pizza ever.

As I have recently moved to Murrumbeena I went around to check out all the different local pizza shops. I was extremely impressed with the quality of ingredients and super friendly staff at Pizzeria 458! It's now my choice of pizza shop in the area.

I had accidently dropped my pizza (still in the box) and the owner even offered to make me another free for charge:)

The 458 is delicious. A tad to the pricy side, and the pizzas are quite light, but highly recommend.

By far the best pizza place in Melbourne! Even their vegetarian pizza tastes better than most pizzas in Melbourne. Price could be a bit cheaper but I guess they know they’re good….

Have had far too many pizzas in my life but this pizza was potentially the best pizza I've had since being in Italy a decade ago. Almost definitely the best pizza I've managed to get ahold of in Australia, (only 1 or 2 come to mind that could potentially compare.) If I could give this 10 stars I absolutely would. Truely phenomenal and deserves lots of recognition!

I approached Alex at 458 Pizzeria to assist with the catering for the Hughesdale Primary School Year 6 graduation dinner. He couldnt not have been more obliging or helpful. The pizzas were delivered and totally fantastic making it a fabulous dinner for our graduates. We cant thankyou enough Alex and team. We are so glad we supported local. 10/10.

Tried 458 for the first time last night and SO glad we did. The pizzas are tasty and authentic, perfect thin base, not soggy and fabulous toppings. Wood fired pizza done right. Kids loved it too. We had the Tropicana, Sopressa and Matteo pizzas and they were all delicious - we've fond our new local pizza place! Also, the staff were super friendly! Keep up the great work, guys, we'll be back for sure.

Wow, that pizza oven in the front window is impressive and it puts out a cracking pizza. I am salivating with anticipation

One of the best pizza I've ever had, staff were great helpful and friendly, would recommend this restaurant for a great pizza experience

This place is amazing! I have been ordering here regularly through DoorDash. The orders are flying out the door and 458 Pizzeria has exceeded my expectations on taste, quality, speed of delivery and value for money. The reviews are true it's a 5 star pizzeria

Tried this pizza for the first time over the weekend and I was not disappointed. Base was perfect, sauce was epic. Best pizza I've had in a long time. Not to mention the owner is a legend! Super friendly.

Worth the wait!
Me and my partner who live local have tried all of the pizza places around and haven’t found the ‘one’
We were counting down the days for 458 to open and man did they blow our socks off, crispy gorgeous crust and base with incredible toppings and they even offer vegan alternatives!
We are stoked you have you In our neighbourhood and we look forward to trying every pizza on your menu.
458 pizzeria you are our ‘one’

I know charcoal is great for your teeth, but to pay $45 for 2 burnt to a crisp pizzas is ridiculous.

Driest pizza I have ever eaten, even drier than ones that have been sitting under the heat lights for hours. Try being not so stingy on the sauce. I ordered off Uber eats and delivery took 8 minutes, however it took over 40 minutes to make my pizza which is surprising since it tasted like it was fresh 5 hours ago.

There's a reason why this place is always packed, the pizza is so good that you'll believe you've somehow been transported to Italy for dinner! Woodfire pizza with quality ingredients and quality service! Well done to Alex and his staff you have nailed it!
Welcome 458 pizzeria to Murrumbeena 10/10

I visited 458 with two of my friends who weren’t well acquainted with gourmet pizza. Alex helped us out and gave us some amazing recommendations. The quality was off the charts and was some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. Highly recommend!

Tried their testing event, and the pepperoni pizza was delicious! Can’t wait for the other toppings they will have in store. Will certainly come back!