Valley Lake Pizzas

Travelling through the area and love to support local, however this was a very big disappointment. The WORST pizza’s we have ever had, the crust was covered in excessive amounts of salt it was revolting. I do not recommend wasting your money go to domino’s instead.

Ordered the Hot and Spicy and also the Nacho Pizza.both were fantastic and they really listened when I asked for "extra spice! " Friendly service on pick up too.

We ordered pizza for 19 of us and everyone LOVED it!
The pizza was delicious and the Slabs are worth every cent! The slab has 24 slices and they’re not small either!
We’ve already decided this is where we will be ordering from when we return for the long weekend next year!

Photo of the Slab boxes for size reference

First visit. NEVER. AGAIN. Being a garlic lover, I ordered the House Special, which boasted the "garlic butter sauce swirl". The pizza was lacking garlic of any description, not even an aroma of garlic on opening the box. My partner had a large Marinara, which consisted of 1 piece each of prawn and octopus, 3 mussels, and 0 anchovies. The pizza's themselves consisted of 90% thick crust pizza dough, and 10% toppings. All for $46. For anyone who loves baked pizza dough on its own, it's still a rip-off.

In response to the owners reply.
Gee, I assumed ordering the House Special ("special" being an oxymoron in this case) it would include the "garlic butter sauce swirl", as stated on YOUR menu. There was NO garlic butter sauce swirl. So because of your incompetence, I should "maybe" order extra garlic at extra expense to myself, as your business runs on a 'hit and miss' policy? NEVER. AGAIN.

Amazing service with prompt delivery and a warm smile.
The pizza was fantastic. Thank you?

We were passing through and starving. Thankfully we picked this place to solve our dilemma. The thick crust warmed the cockles of our heart inspiring nostalgia of satisfying pizzas of past memories. The toppings were fresh and delicious. The man serving had sincere friendliness without being over the top. We were left full, satisfied, and with a happy memory we will take with us for the rest of our life. Thank you. We enjoyed the pizza.

Brought $172 worth of pizza, could see the base through what little topping was on the pizza, i have eaten better pizza from Woolworths.

Paid $71 to feed our family, 3 pizzas, one serve of wedges, with sour cream and sweet chilli sauce. (which came combined in one small container)

Get it home and the pizza was shocked by how small and flat the pizzas where. I ate it and it honestly felt like I was eating cardboard topped with cheese, I couldn't even finish it as it was also extremely salty?

I am beyond disappointed, especially with the cost.

Will not recommend, nor will I be back.

We had to quarantine suddenly (we were visiting from interstate) and even though we were outside the delivery area, they helped us out. Plus, the pizza was awesome! Thanks Mike and the crew! You saved us from starving!

I swapped over to here from dominos and it's one of the best decisions I've ever made. The pizzas are so much better. The toppings are better. The size is better. The cost may be slightly more but it's worth it. You get more than you pay for. Best pizza place in town.

Good pizza, but you can tell that by how busy the place was, takeaways and delivery, friendly staff.

Amazing quality pizza the Slab pizza is huge and amazing value for money. My favourite is the desert pizzas

Hot n Spicy is awesome- we ordered it Medium and they nailed it. Also reccomend the house special. They dont scrimp on toppings and bases are super tasty aswell.fast pick-up and friendly staff.

There were a total of 6 Small prawns on a FAMILY. Pizza about 50 mussels and that's it. VERY DISAPOINTED. NEVER AGAIN! They call it a marinara. What a joke!

Expensive experience for scabby amount of toppings, $11.50 for an 8 inch or regular.
Lovely shop, nice and clean. Friendly young lady taking the orders. Thank you
Thin crust quite nice and with a bit more toppings would be a fantastic pizza

Expensive and pizza was OK but in Mount Gambier there are other pizza places that are cheaper and other places with better pizza so why pay a premium price for OK pizza.

Was disappointed pizza was obviously made on a frozen base with next to no topping on it. I had half marinara half capricossa and to be honest all i could taste was bread and cheese.just another crapy Dominos at best. A waste of good money is the only guarantee.